George W. Bush's new claims about Kerry "flip-flopping" on the war in Afghanistan quickly moved yesterday from the campaign trail to the nightly news. But some journalists who repeated Bush's charges made no effort to examine the truth behind Bush's claims-- claims which turn out, like many other Bush lines of attack, to be deceptive.
Bush charged that while Kerry now criticizes how the administration managed the search for Osama bin Laden in Tora Bora, Kerry made comments at the time that were much different. "In the fall of 2001," Bush charged,
But Bush is taking Kerry's words grossly out of context. Both comments he cited came from an appearance on CNN's Larry King Live (12/14/01). When a viewer asked "why they don't use napalm or flamethrowers on those tunnels and caves up there in Afghanistan," Kerry replied:
"Well, I think it depends on where you are tactically. They may well be doing that at some point in time. But for the moment, what we are doing, I think, is having its impact and it is the best way to protect our troops and sort of minimalize the proximity, if you will. I think we have been doing this pretty effectively and we should continue to do it that way."
In other words, Kerry was suggesting that napalm and flamethrowers might be ill-suited for the mission to find Osama bin Laden.
Bush is incorrect in saying that the other quote was "about Tora Bora"; in fact, that comment came in response to this question from host Larry King: "Senator Kerry--and this is for all of you--how goes it so far in Afghanistan, in your opinion?" A moment's thought reveals the absurdity of comparing one assessment of the situation in Afghanistan--made shortly after the capture of Kabul, when it was believed that bin Laden was surrounded and would soon be captured--with an assessment made later, after bin Laden had slipped away to parts unknown.
Unfortunately, some journalists covering the Bush campaign appearance passed along his allegations, but failed to inform viewers about their accuracy. CNN's John King (10/25/04) talked up the Bush campaign strategy, noting that "another part of their strategy to keep voters moving from Bush to Kerry is to make the case that Senator Kerry has been inconsistent on Iraq." As evidence, King explained that
He then quoted from Bush's speech, but failed to provide the context of Kerry's statements, made on his own network.
NBC Nightly News correspondent David Gregory (10/25/04) also failed to challenge Bush's claims, opting instead to explain Bush's strategy to NBC viewers:
Unfortunately, Gregory did not compare Bush's description of Kerry's words with Kerry's actual remarks.
ACTION: Please contact CNN and NBC News and remind them how critical it is to check the accuracy of charges made in the closing days of the presidential campaign.
CNN, Wolf Blitzer Reports
NBC Nightly News
Phone: (212) 664-4971
As always, please remember that your comments have more impact if you maintain a polite tone. Please send a copy of your correspondence to firstname.lastname@example.org.