Back in May 2013, corporate media outlets expressed alarm at a report from the Treasury Inspector General for Tax Administration (TIGTA) that suggested that from 2010 through 2012, the IRS had applied extra scrutiny to groups applying for tax-exempt status with conservative-sounding names. The report, “based on concerns expressed by members of Congress,” said that 96 groups applying for 501(c)(4) exemptions had been targeted for heightened questioning because of terms like “Tea Party” and “Patriots” in their names.
For Peggy Noonan (Wall Street Journal, 5/17/13), the smoking gun was a fact she made up: “Only conservative groups were targeted, not liberal.”
Media harshly condemned the reported targeting, with Peggy Noonan in the Wall Street Journal (5/17/13) calling it “the worst Washington scandal since Watergate,” one that “threatens the basic integrity of our government.” The former Reagan speechwriter wrote:
It is not even remotely possible that all this was an accident, a mistake. Again, only conservative groups were targeted, not liberal.
Bill O’Reilly and Fox News devoted countless hours covering congressional hearings on testimonies from IRS officials, and Fox Insider devoted pages to speculative and conspiratorial articles with headlines like “‘Caught Red-Handed’” and “‘Sounds Like Chicago Justice.’”
The condemnation was not limited to conservative news sources. The New York Times (5/16/13) played up the IRS targeting as a part of a trio of emerging scandals for the Obama administration, along with the Benghazi attacks and the seizure of journalists’ phone records at the Associated Press. The Washington Post‘s Karen Tumulty (5/15/13) contributed to the hand-wringing about the president’s “scandal trifecta.”
“The most corrosive political scandals are the ones that feed a preexisting story line,” wrote Karen Tumulty (Washington Post, 5/15/13) as she fed a pre-existing storyline.
As the scandal broke, FAIR’s Peter Hart (5/17/13) noted discrepancies between USA Today’s coverage in their print and web articles covering the scandal: While the print version was headlined “IRS Gave a Pass to Liberals,” the web version elaborated on the scrutiny IRS gave Roots Action—a progressive group launched by FAIR founder Jeff Cohen—when it applied for a 501(c)(4) exemption.
The following month (7/24/13), the IRS released heavily redacted documents that showed that the IRS also targeted groups with progressive-sounding names that applied for 501(c)(4) status, flagging terms like “Occupy,” “Progressive,” “Green Energy” and “ACORN Successors,” among 13 others, for further review.
There was minimal coverage of the new information (FAIR.org, 9/25/13), though the New York Times’ Jonathan Weisman (9/24/13) commented that “the new IRS documents raise questions about how the controversy has been portrayed.” Conservative outlets like the Washington Times (6/27/13) continued to feed the narrative of an abuse of executive power directed at Obama’s political opponents.
Now a new TIGTA report (9/28/17) confirms the targeting of progressive groups from 2004 until 2013. In fact, the new report makes clear that not only were progressive groups scrutinized, they were in fact targeted more than conservative groups. A New York Times headline (10/5/17) noted that “In Targeting Political Groups, IRS Crossed Party Lines,” but the article did not elaborate on prior media coverage of the scandal.
The Washington Post (10/5/17) did include some media criticism, singling out CNN and Fox News in particular for their misleading coverage of the issue—but didn’t recall its own portraying the supposed IRS bias as part of a “scandal trifecta.”
Correction: This story initially noted that the May 2013 TIGTA report was in regards to investigations from the years 2004-2013. The article has been corrected to reflect that the May 2013 TIGTA report pertained to the years 2010-2012.
“Democracy Dies in Darkness”
And we control the light switch
Excellent post. File it under #NotSoLiberalMedia.
I appreciate FAIR checking in on this.
I saw the NY Times piece on the recent IG report, and was wondering whether it was just me thinking the article seemed to be willfully silent on the media and political history of this alleged scandal.
I might as well also point out that of three “scandals” that were being played up in May 2013, the only one that seemed to have some merit, the seizure of AP journalists’ phone records, is the one that quickly disappeared without a trace.
Your story is inaccurate. The May 2013 TIGTA audit reviewed the IRS’s handling of applications for tax-exempt status between 2010 to 2012, not between 2004 to 2013. The September 28, 2017 report reviewed applications for tax-exempt status the IRS received between 2004 and 2013. Please correct this. The scope of the reports is entirely different.
You’ve buried too deeply the most important point of this article. You don’t explain the headline until several paragraphs in. You need to put it in the first sentence.
Goodby UNFAIR
As this piece by FAIR proves that once again when fake news and yellow journalism is peddled by “right-wing media” its the “respectable media” those like the Washington Post, CNN, New York Times, the Guardian, and BBC that play an even more critical role in misinforming their readers and viewers.